In 2022-23, two Hockey East players were selected as CCM Hockey All-Americans, with Northeastern's Gwyneth Philips and Alina Mueller both namr to the First Team. The CCM Hockey All-American Teams are selected by the American Hockey Coaches Association.
| Hockey East All-Americans | |||
| 2002-03 | |||
| Jen Huggon | New Hampshire | Sr. | G |
| Kelly Halcisak | Providence | Jr. | D |
2003-04 |
|||
| Chanda Gunn | Northeastern | Sr. | G |
| Kelly Halcisak | Providence | Sr. | D |
2005-06 |
|||
| Martine Garland | New Hampshire | Jr. | D |
| Sadie Wright,Ward | New Hampshire | So. | F |
| Kristin Gigliotti | Providence | Jr. | D |
| Jennifer Hitchcock | New Hampshire | So. | F |
2007-08 |
|||
| Martine Garland | New Hampshire | Sr. | D |
| Dominique Thibault | UConn | So. | F |
2008-09 |
|||
| Kacey Bellamy | New Hampshire | Sr. | D |
| Molly Schaus | Boston College | Jr. | G |
| Kelli Stack | Boston College | Jr. | F |
2009-10 |
|||
| Kelli Paton | New Hampshire | Sr. | F |
| Courtney Birchard | New Hampshire | Jr. | D |
| Florence Schelling | Northeastern | So. | G |
2010-11 |
|||
| Molly Schaus | Boston College | Sr. | G |
| Kelli Stack | Boston College | Sr. | F |
| Catherine Ward | Boston University | Sr. | D |
2011-12 |
|||
| Florence Schelling | Northeastern | Sr. | G |
2012-13 |
|||
| Blake Bolden | Boston College | Sr. | D |
| Alex Carpenter | Boston College | So. | F |
| Kendall Coyne | Northeastern | So. | F |
2013-14 |
|||
| Sarah Lefort | Boston University | So. | F |
2014-15 |
|||
| Emily Pfalzer | Boston College | Sr. | D |
| Alex Carpenter | Boston College | Jr. | F |
| Marie-Philip Poulin | Boston University | Sr. | F |
| Kendall Coyne | Northeastern | Jr. | F |
2015-16 |
|||
| Alex Carpenter | Boston College | Sr. | F |
| Kendall Coyne | Northeastern | Sr. | F |
| Megan Keller | Boston College | So. | D |
| Elaine Chuli | UConn | Sr. | G |
| Haley Skarupa | Boston College | Sr. | F |
2016-17 |
|||
| Megan Keller | Boston College | Jr. | D |
2017-18 |
|||
| Victoria Bach | Boston University | Sr. | F |
| Daryl Watts | Boston College | Fr. | F |
| Caitrin Lonergan | Boston College | So. | F |
| Toni Ann Miano | Boston College | Sr. | D |
2018-19 |
|||
| Megan Keller | Boston College | Sr. | D |
| Jesse Compher | Boston University | So. | F |
| Skylar Fontaine | Northeastern | So. | D |
| Alina Mueller | Northeastern | Fr. | F |
2019-20 |
|||
| Aerin Frankel | Northeastern | Jr. | G |
| Alina Mueller | Northeastern | So. | F |
| Skylar Fontaine | Northeastern | Jr. | D |
2020-21 |
|||
| Aerin Frankel | Northeastern | Sr. | G |
| Skylar Fontaine | Northeastern | Sr. | D |
| Alina Mueller | Northeastern | Jr. | F |
| Cayla Barnes | Boston College | Jr. | D |
| Chloe Aurard | Northeastern | Jr. | F |
2021-22 |
|||
| Aerin Frankel | Northeastern | Gr. | G |
| Skylar Fontaine | Northeastern | Gr. | D |
| Theresa Schafzahl | Vermont | Sr. | F |
| Alina Mueller | Northeastern | Sr. | F |
| Maureen Murphy | Northeastern | Gr. | F |
| Maude Poulin-Labelle | Vermont | Sr. | D |
2022-23 |
|||
| Alina Mueller | Northeastern | Gr. | F |
| Gwyneth Philips | Northeastern | Sr. | G |
Bold indicates First Team |
|||
