A total of 249 All-Americans (122 First-Team, 127 Second-Team) have played in the 38-year history of the league. In 2003-04, Hockey East set a record with 11 of the 12 Eastern All-Americans coming from Hockey East. The CCM Hockey All-American Teams are selected by the American Hockey Coaches Association.

Hockey East All-Americans
1984-85
Tim Army Providence F
Chris Terreri Providence G
Jim Averill Northeastern D
Doug Brown Boston College F
Bob Sweeney Boston College F
Peter Taglianetti Providence D

1985-86
Scott Harlow Boston College F
Doug Brown Boston College F
John Cullen Boston University F
Clark Donatelli Boston University F
Jay Octeau Boston University D
Chris Terreri Providence G

1986-87
Craig Janney Boston College F
Brian Leetch Boston College D
Bruce Racine Northeastern G
Jon Morris Lowell F
Kevin Stevens Boston College F
Eric Weinrich Maine D

1987-88
David Capuano Maine F
Jack Capuano Maine D
Bruce Racine Northeastern G
Gord Cruickshank Providence F
Brian Dowd Northeastern D
Mike Golden Maine F
Mike McHugh Maine F

1988-89
Greg Brown Boston College D
David Capuano Maine F
Bob Beers Maine D
Rick Bennett Providence F
David Littman Boston College G
Tim Sweeney Boston College F

1989-90
Greg Brown Boston College D
Rob Cowie Northeastern D
David Emma Boston College F
Steve Heinze Boston College F
Keith Carney Maine D
Jean-Yves Roy Maine F

1990-91
Keith Carney Maine D
David Emma Boston College F
Shawn McEachern Boston University F
Jean-Yves Roy Maine F
Peter Ahola Boston University D
Ted Crowley Boston College D
Jeff Levy New Hampshire G
Jim Montgomery Maine F

1991-92
Scott Pellerin Maine F
Jean-Yves Roy Maine F
David Sacco Boston University F
Domenic Amodeo New Hampshire F
Tom Dion Boston University D
Rob Gaudreau Providence D
Scott LaGrand Boston College G

1992-93
Mike Dunham Maine G
Chris Imes Maine D
Paul Kariya Maine F
David Sacco Boston University F
Cal Ingraham Maine F
Kaj Linna Boston University D
Jim Montgomery Maine F

1993-94
Mike Pomichter Boston University F
Dwayne Roloson UMass Lowell G
Rich Brennan Boston University D
Shane Henry UMass Lowell F
Jacques Joubert Boston University F
J.P. McKersie Boston University G
Chad Quenneville Providence F

1994-95
Blair Allison Maine G
Greg Bullock UMass Lowell F
Mike Grier Boston University F
Chris Imes Maine D
Kaj Linna Boston University D
Chris O’Sullivan Boston University F
Chad Quenneville Providence F
Jeff Tory Maine D

1995-96
Dan McGillis Northeastern D
Jay Pandolfo Boston University F
Jeff Tory Maine D
Jon Coleman Boston University D
Chris Drury Boston University F

1996-97
Jon Coleman Boston University D
Chris Drury Boston University F
Chris Kelleher Boston University D
Jason Krog New Hampshire F
Tim Murray New Hampshire D

1997-98
Chris Drury Boston University F
Mark Mowers New Hampshire F
Marty Reasoner Boston College F
Tom Poti Boston University D
Marc Robitaille Northeastern G
Brian Gionta Boston College F
Chris Kelleher Boston University D
Mike Mottau Boston College D

1998-99
David Cullen Maine D
Brian Gionta Boston College F
Steve Kariya Maine F
Jason Krog New Hampshire F
Mike Mottau Boston College D
Jayme Filipowicz New Hampshire D
Michel Larocque Boston University G
Rejean Stringer Merrimack F

1999-2000
Jeff Farkas Boston College F
Brian Gionta Boston College F
Mike Mottau Boston College D
Ty Conklin New Hampshire G
Chris DyMainent Boston University D
Cory Larose Maine F

2000-01
Bobby Allen Boston College D
Ty Conklin New Hampshire G
Brian Gionta Boston College F
Carl Corazzini Boston University F
Ron Hainsey UMass Lowell D
Krys Kolanos Boston College F
Devin Rask Providence F
Nolan Schaefer Providence G

2001-02
Jim Fahey Northeastern D
Darren Haydar New Hampshire F
Colin Hemingway New Hampshire F
Niko Dimitrakos Maine F
Chris Dyment Boston University D
Ben Eaves Boston College F
Peter Metcalf Maine D

2002-03
Ben Eaves Boston College F
Freddy Meyer Boston University D
Mike Ayers New Hampshire G
J.D. Forrest Boston College D
Lanny Gare New Hampshire F
Colin Hemingway New Hampshire F

2003-04
Andrew Alberts Boston College D
Thomas Pöck Massachusetts D
Steve Saviano New Hampshire F
Tony Voce Boston College F
Patrick Eaves Boston College F
Jimmy Howard Maine G
Todd Jackson Maine F
Prestin Ryan Maine D
Ryan Shannon Boston College F
Colin Shields Maine F
Stephen Wood Providence D

2004-05
Andrew Alberts Boston College D
Sean Collins New Hampshire F
Patrick Eaves Boston College F
Jason Guerriero Northeastern F
Ryan Shannon Boston College F
Brian Yandle New Hampshire D

2005-06
Chris Collins Boston College F
Peter Harrold Boston College D
Greg Moore Maine F
Dan Spang Boston University D
Cory Schneider Boston College G
Brian Boyle Boston College F
John Curry Boston University G
Michel Léveillé Maine F
Brian Yandle New Hampshire D

2006-07
Brian Boyle Boston College F
John Curry Boston University G
Michel Léveillé Maine F
Matt Gilroy Boston University D
Jon Quick Massachusetts G
Trevor Smith New Hampshire F
Sean Sullivan Boston University D

2007-08
Nathan Gerbe Boston College F
Matt Gilroy Boston University D
Mike Radja New Hampshire F
Kevin Regan New Hampshire G
Bryan Ewing Boston University F
Matt Fornataro New Hampshire F
Brad Flaishans New Hampshire D
Pete MacArthur Boston University F

2008-09
Matt Gilroy Boston University D
Viktor Stålberg Vermont F
Brad Thiessen Northeastern G
Colin Wilson Boston University F
Maury Edwards UMass Lowell D
Jamees Marcou Massachusetts F
Kevin Shattenkirk Boston University D

2009-10
Bobby Butler New Hampshire F
Colby Cohen Boston University D
Gustav Nyquist Maine F
Justin Braun Massachusetts D
Brian Foster New Hampshire G
Blake Kessel New Hampshire D

2010-11
Cam Atkinson Boston College F
Brian Dumoulin Boston College D
Blake Kessel New Hampshire D
Paul Thompson New Hampshire F
Stephane Da Costa Merrimack F
John Muse Boston College G
Gustav Nyquist Maine F

2011-12
Spencer Abbott Maine F
Brian Dumoulin Boston College D
Barry Almeida Boston College F
Joe Cannata Merrimack G

2012-13
Johnny Gaudreau Boston College F
Chad Ruhwedel UMass Lowell D
Trevor van Riemsdyk New Hampshire D
Steven Whitney Boston College F
Mike Collins Merrimack F
Jon Gillies Providence G

2013-14
Johnny Gaudreau Boston College F
Kevin Hayes Boston College F
Connor Hellebuyck UMass Lowell G
Ben Hutton Maine D
Michael Matheson Boston College D
Devin Shore Maine F

2014-15
Matt Grzelcyk Boston University D
Jack Eichel Boston University F
Jon Gillies Providence G
Mike Paliotta Vermont D
Robbie Russo Notre Dame D
Kevin Roy Northeastern F

2015-16
Matt Grzelcyk Boston University D
Jake Walman Providence D
Andrew Poturalski New Hampshire F
Thatcher Demko Boston College G
Ryan Fitzgerald Boston College F
Danny O’Regan Boston University F

2016-17
Zach Aston-Reese Northeastern F
Charlie McAvoy Boston University D
Anders Bjork Notre Dame F
Tyler Kelleher New Hampshire F
Jake Walman Providence D
Dylan Zink UMass Lowell D

2017-18
Jeremy Davies Northeastern D
Adam Gaudette Northeastern F
Dylan Sikura Northeastern F
Jacob Bryson Providence D

2018-19
Mitchell Chaffee Massachusetts F
Cale Makar Massachusetts D
Cayden Primeau Northeastern G
David Cotton Boston College F
Jeremy Davies Northeastern D
Josh Wilkins Providence F

2019-20
Jack Dugan Providence F
David Farrance Boston University D
John Leonard Massachusetts F
Jeremy Swayman Maine G
Tyler Madden Northeastern F

2020-21
Matt Boldy Boston College F
David Farrance Boston University D
Spencer Knight Boston College G
Bobby Trivigno Massachusetts F
Johnny Evans UConn F
Drew Helleson Boston College F
Zac Jones Massachusetts D

2021-2022
Devon Levi Northeastern G
Aidan McDonough Northeastern F
Scott Morrow Massachusetts D
Bobby Trivigno Massachusetts F
Jordan Harris Northeastern D
Jack McBain Boston College F
Ryan Tverberg UConn F

2022-2023
Lane Hutson Massachusetts D
Devon Levi Northeastern G
Aidan McDonough Northeastern F
Matt Brown Boston University F
Alex Jefferies Merrimack F

Bold indicates First Team