A total of 249 All-Americans (122 First-Team, 127 Second-Team) have played in the 38-year history of the league. In 2003-04, Hockey East set a record with 11 of the 12 Eastern All-Americans coming from Hockey East. The CCM Hockey All-American Teams are selected by the American Hockey Coaches Association.
| Hockey East All-Americans | ||
| 1984-85 | ||
| Tim Army | Providence | F |
| Chris Terreri | Providence | G |
| Jim Averill | Northeastern | D |
| Doug Brown | Boston College | F |
| Bob Sweeney | Boston College | F |
| Peter Taglianetti | Providence | D |
1985-86 |
||
| Scott Harlow | Boston College | F |
| Doug Brown | Boston College | F |
| John Cullen | Boston University | F |
| Clark Donatelli | Boston University | F |
| Jay Octeau | Boston University | D |
| Chris Terreri | Providence | G |
1986-87 |
||
| Craig Janney | Boston College | F |
| Brian Leetch | Boston College | D |
| Bruce Racine | Northeastern | G |
| Jon Morris | Lowell | F |
| Kevin Stevens | Boston College | F |
| Eric Weinrich | Maine | D |
1987-88 |
||
| David Capuano | Maine | F |
| Jack Capuano | Maine | D |
| Bruce Racine | Northeastern | G |
| Gord Cruickshank | Providence | F |
| Brian Dowd | Northeastern | D |
| Mike Golden | Maine | F |
| Mike McHugh | Maine | F |
1988-89 |
||
| Greg Brown | Boston College | D |
| David Capuano | Maine | F |
| Bob Beers | Maine | D |
| Rick Bennett | Providence | F |
| David Littman | Boston College | G |
| Tim Sweeney | Boston College | F |
1989-90 |
||
| Greg Brown | Boston College | D |
| Rob Cowie | Northeastern | D |
| David Emma | Boston College | F |
| Steve Heinze | Boston College | F |
| Keith Carney | Maine | D |
| Jean-Yves Roy | Maine | F |
1990-91 |
||
| Keith Carney | Maine | D |
| David Emma | Boston College | F |
| Shawn McEachern | Boston University | F |
| Jean-Yves Roy | Maine | F |
| Peter Ahola | Boston University | D |
| Ted Crowley | Boston College | D |
| Jeff Levy | New Hampshire | G |
| Jim Montgomery | Maine | F |
1991-92 |
||
| Scott Pellerin | Maine | F |
| Jean-Yves Roy | Maine | F |
| David Sacco | Boston University | F |
| Domenic Amodeo | New Hampshire | F |
| Tom Dion | Boston University | D |
| Rob Gaudreau | Providence | D |
| Scott LaGrand | Boston College | G |
1992-93 |
||
| Mike Dunham | Maine | G |
| Chris Imes | Maine | D |
| Paul Kariya | Maine | F |
| David Sacco | Boston University | F |
| Cal Ingraham | Maine | F |
| Kaj Linna | Boston University | D |
| Jim Montgomery | Maine | F |
1993-94 |
||
| Mike Pomichter | Boston University | F |
| Dwayne Roloson | UMass Lowell | G |
| Rich Brennan | Boston University | D |
| Shane Henry | UMass Lowell | F |
| Jacques Joubert | Boston University | F |
| J.P. McKersie | Boston University | G |
| Chad Quenneville | Providence | F |
1994-95 |
||
| Blair Allison | Maine | G |
| Greg Bullock | UMass Lowell | F |
| Mike Grier | Boston University | F |
| Chris Imes | Maine | D |
| Kaj Linna | Boston University | D |
| Chris O’Sullivan | Boston University | F |
| Chad Quenneville | Providence | F |
| Jeff Tory | Maine | D |
1995-96 |
||
| Dan McGillis | Northeastern | D |
| Jay Pandolfo | Boston University | F |
| Jeff Tory | Maine | D |
| Jon Coleman | Boston University | D |
| Chris Drury | Boston University | F |
1996-97 |
||
| Jon Coleman | Boston University | D |
| Chris Drury | Boston University | F |
| Chris Kelleher | Boston University | D |
| Jason Krog | New Hampshire | F |
| Tim Murray | New Hampshire | D |
1997-98 |
||
| Chris Drury | Boston University | F |
| Mark Mowers | New Hampshire | F |
| Marty Reasoner | Boston College | F |
| Tom Poti | Boston University | D |
| Marc Robitaille | Northeastern | G |
| Brian Gionta | Boston College | F |
| Chris Kelleher | Boston University | D |
| Mike Mottau | Boston College | D |
1998-99 |
||
| David Cullen | Maine | D |
| Brian Gionta | Boston College | F |
| Steve Kariya | Maine | F |
| Jason Krog | New Hampshire | F |
| Mike Mottau | Boston College | D |
| Jayme Filipowicz | New Hampshire | D |
| Michel Larocque | Boston University | G |
| Rejean Stringer | Merrimack | F |
1999-2000 |
||
| Jeff Farkas | Boston College | F |
| Brian Gionta | Boston College | F |
| Mike Mottau | Boston College | D |
| Ty Conklin | New Hampshire | G |
| Chris DyMainent | Boston University | D |
| Cory Larose | Maine | F |
2000-01 |
||
| Bobby Allen | Boston College | D |
| Ty Conklin | New Hampshire | G |
| Brian Gionta | Boston College | F |
| Carl Corazzini | Boston University | F |
| Ron Hainsey | UMass Lowell | D |
| Krys Kolanos | Boston College | F |
| Devin Rask | Providence | F |
| Nolan Schaefer | Providence | G |
2001-02 |
||
| Jim Fahey | Northeastern | D |
| Darren Haydar | New Hampshire | F |
| Colin Hemingway | New Hampshire | F |
| Niko Dimitrakos | Maine | F |
| Chris Dyment | Boston University | D |
| Ben Eaves | Boston College | F |
| Peter Metcalf | Maine | D |
2002-03 |
||
| Ben Eaves | Boston College | F |
| Freddy Meyer | Boston University | D |
| Mike Ayers | New Hampshire | G |
| J.D. Forrest | Boston College | D |
| Lanny Gare | New Hampshire | F |
| Colin Hemingway | New Hampshire | F |
2003-04 |
||
| Andrew Alberts | Boston College | D |
| Thomas Pöck | Massachusetts | D |
| Steve Saviano | New Hampshire | F |
| Tony Voce | Boston College | F |
| Patrick Eaves | Boston College | F |
| Jimmy Howard | Maine | G |
| Todd Jackson | Maine | F |
| Prestin Ryan | Maine | D |
| Ryan Shannon | Boston College | F |
| Colin Shields | Maine | F |
| Stephen Wood | Providence | D |
2004-05 |
||
| Andrew Alberts | Boston College | D |
| Sean Collins | New Hampshire | F |
| Patrick Eaves | Boston College | F |
| Jason Guerriero | Northeastern | F |
| Ryan Shannon | Boston College | F |
| Brian Yandle | New Hampshire | D |
2005-06 |
||
| Chris Collins | Boston College | F |
| Peter Harrold | Boston College | D |
| Greg Moore | Maine | F |
| Dan Spang | Boston University | D |
| Cory Schneider | Boston College | G |
| Brian Boyle | Boston College | F |
| John Curry | Boston University | G |
| Michel Léveillé | Maine | F |
| Brian Yandle | New Hampshire | D |
2006-07 |
||
| Brian Boyle | Boston College | F |
| John Curry | Boston University | G |
| Michel Léveillé | Maine | F |
| Matt Gilroy | Boston University | D |
| Jon Quick | Massachusetts | G |
| Trevor Smith | New Hampshire | F |
| Sean Sullivan | Boston University | D |
2007-08 |
||
| Nathan Gerbe | Boston College | F |
| Matt Gilroy | Boston University | D |
| Mike Radja | New Hampshire | F |
| Kevin Regan | New Hampshire | G |
| Bryan Ewing | Boston University | F |
| Matt Fornataro | New Hampshire | F |
| Brad Flaishans | New Hampshire | D |
| Pete MacArthur | Boston University | F |
2008-09 |
||
| Matt Gilroy | Boston University | D |
| Viktor Stålberg | Vermont | F |
| Brad Thiessen | Northeastern | G |
| Colin Wilson | Boston University | F |
| Maury Edwards | UMass Lowell | D |
| Jamees Marcou | Massachusetts | F |
| Kevin Shattenkirk | Boston University | D |
2009-10 |
||
| Bobby Butler | New Hampshire | F |
| Colby Cohen | Boston University | D |
| Gustav Nyquist | Maine | F |
| Justin Braun | Massachusetts | D |
| Brian Foster | New Hampshire | G |
| Blake Kessel | New Hampshire | D |
2010-11 |
||
| Cam Atkinson | Boston College | F |
| Brian Dumoulin | Boston College | D |
| Blake Kessel | New Hampshire | D |
| Paul Thompson | New Hampshire | F |
| Stephane Da Costa | Merrimack | F |
| John Muse | Boston College | G |
| Gustav Nyquist | Maine | F |
2011-12 |
||
| Spencer Abbott | Maine | F |
| Brian Dumoulin | Boston College | D |
| Barry Almeida | Boston College | F |
| Joe Cannata | Merrimack | G |
2012-13 |
||
| Johnny Gaudreau | Boston College | F |
| Chad Ruhwedel | UMass Lowell | D |
| Trevor van Riemsdyk | New Hampshire | D |
| Steven Whitney | Boston College | F |
| Mike Collins | Merrimack | F |
| Jon Gillies | Providence | G |
2013-14 |
||
| Johnny Gaudreau | Boston College | F |
| Kevin Hayes | Boston College | F |
| Connor Hellebuyck | UMass Lowell | G |
| Ben Hutton | Maine | D |
| Michael Matheson | Boston College | D |
| Devin Shore | Maine | F |
2014-15 |
||
| Matt Grzelcyk | Boston University | D |
| Jack Eichel | Boston University | F |
| Jon Gillies | Providence | G |
| Mike Paliotta | Vermont | D |
| Robbie Russo | Notre Dame | D |
| Kevin Roy | Northeastern | F |
2015-16 |
||
| Matt Grzelcyk | Boston University | D |
| Jake Walman | Providence | D |
| Andrew Poturalski | New Hampshire | F |
| Thatcher Demko | Boston College | G |
| Ryan Fitzgerald | Boston College | F |
| Danny O’Regan | Boston University | F |
2016-17 |
||
| Zach Aston-Reese | Northeastern | F |
| Charlie McAvoy | Boston University | D |
| Anders Bjork | Notre Dame | F |
| Tyler Kelleher | New Hampshire | F |
| Jake Walman | Providence | D |
| Dylan Zink | UMass Lowell | D |
2017-18 |
||
| Jeremy Davies | Northeastern | D |
| Adam Gaudette | Northeastern | F |
| Dylan Sikura | Northeastern | F |
| Jacob Bryson | Providence | D |
2018-19 |
||
| Mitchell Chaffee | Massachusetts | F |
| Cale Makar | Massachusetts | D |
| Cayden Primeau | Northeastern | G |
| David Cotton | Boston College | F |
| Jeremy Davies | Northeastern | D |
| Josh Wilkins | Providence | F |
2019-20 |
||
| Jack Dugan | Providence | F |
| David Farrance | Boston University | D |
| John Leonard | Massachusetts | F |
| Jeremy Swayman | Maine | G |
| Tyler Madden | Northeastern | F |
2020-21 |
||
| Matt Boldy | Boston College | F |
| David Farrance | Boston University | D |
| Spencer Knight | Boston College | G |
| Bobby Trivigno | Massachusetts | F |
| Johnny Evans | UConn | F |
| Drew Helleson | Boston College | F |
| Zac Jones | Massachusetts | D |
2021-2022 |
||
| Devon Levi | Northeastern | G |
| Aidan McDonough | Northeastern | F |
| Scott Morrow | Massachusetts | D |
| Bobby Trivigno | Massachusetts | F |
| Jordan Harris | Northeastern | D |
| Jack McBain | Boston College | F |
| Ryan Tverberg | UConn | F |
2022-2023 |
||
| Lane Hutson | Massachusetts | D |
| Devon Levi | Northeastern | G |
| Aidan McDonough | Northeastern | F |
| Matt Brown | Boston University | F |
| Alex Jefferies | Merrimack | F |
Bold indicates First Team |
||
